If you love eating toasted sandwiches, you need to get yourself some toaster bags to slot into the toaster, so that you can make your own snacks whenever the craving strikes. Some of them can also be used in the oven, air fryer, grill or microwave too, making it much easier to heat up your favourite foods.
Let's face it, sometimes we can't be bothered to get the toastie maker out and then clean it afterwards, which is why these toaster bags come in so handy. All you need to do is make the sarnie and then pop it into the bag, ready for heating.
Best toaster bags at a glance
•Best for being washable: Toastabags Toast Bags - view offer on Amazon
•Best for reusability: 2 Lakeland Toastabags - view offer on Lakeland
•Best for a budget: Sealapack Reusable Toastie Sandwich Bags - view offer on Amazon
As well as cooking bread, you can use toastie bags to reheat all sorts of things including pizza slices and cookies to name a few. If you have celiac disease, you can use toaster bags for gluten-free food preparation to avoid cross-contamination.
We've compiled a list of the very best toaster bags, including multipacks and reusable options. Don't forget to check out the FAQs at the bottom of the round-up for more information on how to use a toaster bag.
Best toaster bags
Best for being washable
Toastabags is one of the best go-to brands as their bags are reusable and dishwasher-safe. They are easy to clean as you can simply turn them inside out to reach all of the corners. You should be able to use each one at least 50 times... that's a lot of sandwiches!
One reviewer said: "These toast bags have been a game-changer for me, especially since I use them for gluten-free bread. They keep my gluten-free slices separate from other crumbs in the toaster and prevent cross-contamination. It's a must-have for anyone with dietary restrictions. Five stars for convenience and peace of mind!"
Pros
- Dishwasher safe
- Suitable for freezing
Cons
- Some users say that they're on the small side
| Number of bags: | 10 |
| Reusable?: | Yes |
| Size: | 21 x 16.5 x 0.5 cm |
Best for reusability
www.lakeland.co.uk
Made out of a non-stick material, we recommend these Lakeland toaster bags for grilled cheese and other toasted goods. They can be reused up to 500 times and they have handles so that you can take them out of the toaster with ease.
A reviewer wrote: "These are great for all the cheese toasties I am making for my Mum. Make lots of cheese sandwiches, put each one in a self seal storage food bag and freeze. She takes one out in the morning and pops into her Toastabag and then into her toaster ready for lunch - she loves them and keeps her independent - thank you Lakeland."
Pros
- Durable composition
- Handles on both bags
Cons
- Quite long
| Number of bags: | 2 |
| Dishwasher safe?: | Yes |
| Size: | 15 x 20cm (6" x 8") |
Best for sturdiness
Available as a pack of two, these KitchenCraft bags for toasters are ideal for couples who enjoy a toasted sandwich break together. They are reusable and they have a non-stick coating, allowing you to expertly extract your sarnie without leaving behind half of the contents.
Susan, a reviewer said: "These toastie Bags are wonderful to use, they are sturdy and it is easy to get the sandwiches inside. They can go in the dishwasher, and because they are sturdy they stay in place and do not fold over. I am delighted with them. I would recommend these to everybody who likes toasted sandwiches."
Pros
- Durable design
- No need to add oil
Cons
- Small
| Number of bags: | 2 |
| Dishwasher safe?: | Yes |
| Size: | 20.5 x 14.5 cm |
Best for a budget
Available in various pack quantities (two per pack), the Sealapack toastie sandwich bags can help you to make deliciously cooked sarnies in a fuss-free and mess-free way.
Jenna, a reviewer put: "I remember having these as a kid so I recently purchased a few to show my partner… We’re now absolutely addicted to toasties now and he can’t believe how easy it is. You just have to make a sandwich, slip it in the bag and pop it into the toaster and within minutes you have a luscious little toasty on the go. I would 1000% recommend to anyone going through a toastie phase!"
Pros
- Affordable price
- Good size
Cons
- A couple of reviewers said that they're tricky to clean
| Number of bags: | 4 |
| Dishwasher safe?: | No |
| Size: | 26.5 x 17.7 x 1 cm |
Best for a budget
www.dunelm.com
We love the versatility of Toastabags! You can freeze them, put them in the oven or microwave and even place them on a cycle in the dishwasher to rinse them out. They are made out of woven fibre glass which has been coated in PTFE, making them heat-safe.
A reviewer wrote: "These bags are great value and easy to use. They are less hassle than cleaning a sandwich toaster and I use these a lot, toasted cheese and chutney is my favourite (take care to let the chutney cool a little though). I have a sandwich toaster but I never use it because it takes a lot of cleaning - these are an ideal and sensibly priced replacement."
Pros
- Comes with 20 recipes
- Packaging is recyclable
Cons
- Not resistant to tearing
| Number of bags: | 2 |
| Dishwasher safe?: | Yes |
| Size: | 21 x 16.5 x 0.5 cm |
Best for an alternative
www.johnlewis.com
Similarly to toasted sandwich bags, the NoStik Toastie Sleeves from John Lewis can be slotted into the toaster with your food. It holds the bread and the filling together, and any cheese or leakages can be caught by the netting, preventing them from dripping into your toaster.
One happy reviewer put: "We like these sleeves very much. They toast the bread evenly and the fillings are hot enough. The sleeves are quite hot when first out of the toaster and they're easy to clean."
Pros
- Suitable for any thickness of bread
- Hardy fibreglass
Cons
- Some say that they're too rigid
| Number of bags: | 2 |
| Dishwasher safe?: | Yes |
| Size: | H17 x W14cm |
How to use toaster bags
There are many ways to use a toaster bag, but the main way is to make your sandwich (with all of your favourite fillings), pop it into the bag and then place into it the toaster slot. You should then set your toaster to cook for a couple of minutes and wait until it pops up. If you’re unsure, check it regularly and toast it for longer if you prefer a more toasted sarnie.
The beauty of a 2-slot or 4-slice toaster means that you can make multiple toasted sandwiches or reheat multiple things at the same time, which is perfect if you're saving a snack for later or eating with a friend or family member.
How to use reusable toaster bags
If you are using reusable bags, the concept is the same, except you don't throw them away. Instead, you can either hand wash them with warm soapy water and leave them on the draining board to dry, or you can place them on a cycle in a dishwasher (depending on what the packaging says).
Are toaster bags safe?
Most toaster bags are fine to use, as long as you follow the instructions on the packet. Do not leave your bag in the toaster, oven or microwave for longer than recommended and don't put it onto an open flame. Remember to throw away used toaster bags or thoroughly wash them again before use.
Arabella Horspool is a Commercial Content Writer for Mother & Baby and Yours. She enjoys reading, creative writing, spending time with her pets and cooking for her friends and family.